Discuto

Discuto

How the discuto consensus meter works


A well know danger of partipatory decision making is the "design by committee phenomen", a term "used to refer to suboptimal traits that such a process may produce as a result of having to compromise between the requirements and viewpoints of the participants, particularly in the presence of poor leadership or poor technical knowledge, such as needless complexity, internal inconsistency, logical flaws, banality, and the lack of a unifying vision." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_by_committee).

To prevent this dilution of a concept laid down in a document discuto employs a patented method to indicate which paragraphs to change and which to better leave as they are.

Let me briefly explain the logic of this method based on an example. After  participants have voted on the first version of a document one will most probably end up with some disagreeing votes. In some cases one might be able to get rid of all of these through modifications that accomodate comments. However, this becomes more unlikely the higher the number of participants and paragraphs and it also might well be that one ends up with an increased number of negative votes as in the case of conflicting viewpoints changes made to accomodate dissenters might not be acceptable to consenters of the original version.

In such cases it makes sense to concentrate the efforts on those paragraphs where there is a significant number of disagreements. A simple strategy would be to change those paragraphs where the number of negative votes exceeds the number of positive votes in any case and to modify the other paragraphs only if one is confident that the new formulation is also acceptable to initial consenters. With discuto, one can easily spot these paragraphs via the red-green bar besides the paragraph text, and discuto also automatically notifies the participants that voted on a changed paragraph that a new version is ready for evaluation.

However, this strategy also has its drawbacks. Consider the example discussion given in Table 1. Here, a document comprised of 8 paragraphs P1 to P8 has been discussed by participants E1 to E9. A cell in the resulting voting matrix contains the respective voting, where 1 stands for consent, -1 for a negative vote and 0 for the case when the participant did not vote for the respective paragraph.

Table 1: First Voting Matrix

Paragraph

Participant

P1

P2

P3

P4

P5

P6

P7

P8

Neg. Votes

Neu. Votes

E1

-1

1

1

1

1

1

0

0

1

2

E2

-1

0

0

1

0

0

0

-1

2

5

E3

0

1

0

1

1

1

0

-1

1

3

E4

-1

1

1

0

0

0

-1

0

2

4

E5

0

0

0

1

1

0

-1

-1

2

4

E6

1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

1

1

4

1

E7

1

0

-1

-1

-1

-1

1

0

4

2

E8

1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

1

1

4

1

E9

1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

0

1

4

2

Sum

1

0

-2

1

1

-2

1

0

24

24

In this example, paragraphs P3 and P6 have more negative votes than positive ones and therefore should be changed according to our strategy. If the initially consenting participants E1-E4 disagree with the new version while the initially dissenting ones E5-E9 agree to it the voting matrix given in table 2 arises.

Table 2: Expected Voting Matrix after Modifying C3 and C6

Paragraph

Participant

P1

P2

P3

P4

P5

P6

P7

P8

Neg. Votes

Neu. Votes

E1

-1

1

-1

1

1

-1

0

0

3

2

E2

-1

0

0

1

0

0

0

-1

2

5

E3

0

1

0

1

1

-1

0

-1

2

3

E4

-1

1

-1

0

0

0

-1

0

3

4

E5

0

0

0

1

1

0

-1

-1

2

4

E6

1

-1

1

-1

0

1

1

1

2

1

E7

1

0

1

-1

-1

1

1

0

2

2

E8

1

-1

1

-1

0

1

1

1

2

1

E9

1

-1

1

0

-1

1

0

1

2

2

Sum

1

0

2

1

1

2

1

0

20

24

Is this new version of the document an improvement over the old one in terms of agreement by the participants? Cleary, the total number of negative votes has descreased from 24 to 20. Also, the distribution of disagreements has become more evenly. In the original version participants E1 and E3 only had one paragraph they did not like, while E5 to E9 had problems with half of the content. Now all participants object to at least two paragraphs, and E1 and E4 to three. If a compromise with median acceptance is your goal this is fine. However, contentwise such a strategy often leads to a dilution of your original idea, as exemplified by the opening proverb “A camel is a horse designed by committee”. In many cases, it is therefore better to intentionally ignore comments by participants who are critical of a larger number of paragraphs and to incorporate only those changes that are proposed by participants who are overal positive. In our example, for instance, changing paragaphs P1, P7, and P8 can leed to the total satisfaction of participants E1 to E5.

Table 3: Voting Matrix  after Modifying P1, P7 and P8

Paragraph

Participant

P1

P2

P3

P4

P5

P6

P7

P8

Neg. Votes

Neu. Votes

E1

1

1

1

1

1

1

0

0

0

2

E2

1

0

0

1

0

0

0

1

0

5

E3

0

1

0

1

1

1

0

1

0

3

E4

1

1

1

0

0

0

1

0

0

4

E5

0

0

0

1

1

0

1

1

0

4

E6

-1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

-1

7

1

E7

-1

0

-1

-1

-1

-1

-1

0

6

2

E8

-1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

-1

7

1

E9

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

0

-1

6

2

Sum

-1

0

-2

1

1

-2

-1

0

26

24

The discuto consensus meter automates such analyses. Discuto assigns a higher weight to possible reductions of negative votes / increases of positive votes of participants with a lower number of disgreements. In our example, for instance, discuto weights a change that can reduce the number of negative votes of participant E1 three times higher than a change that consents participant E9. The ratio of the sum of weights of participants that dissented to the sum of weights of participants who consented is then used to rate the paragraphs. Change is strongly recommended for paragraphs where this ratio is equal or larger than 1, while change is not recommened if the ratio is 0. Values between these extremes indicate the strength of the change recommendation for the respective paragraph.

Figure 1: Number of Disagreements in national research strategy discussion


As can be seen from the number of disagreements per participant in a discussion af a national research strategy in figure 1 this differentiation among the participants becomes more profound the larger the number of paragraphs and participants is. The discuto consensus meter is especially valuable in such cases, as here the sheer size of the feedback obtained necessitates a clear focus on the most valuable improvement opportunities.


About the author :

Alfred Taudes

Alfred Taudes is Professor for Business Administration and Business Informatics at the Vienna University of Economics and Business. His fields of expertise include strategy, knowledge management, process management, information systems and innovation. He has published over 100 articles in international professional journals and holds various scientific awards. He has supervised many international large-scale science projects and held professorships in Germany and Japan. Promoting new ideas through third party funded projects, scientific advice and the support of spin-offs has always been a core aspect of his work.


Login or register to post comments
image_ava
grourge 18.10.2022 - 00:39
buy">https://bestcialis20mg.com]buy generic cialis online cheap Comparison of the effect of antihormones on the RNA expression of the nine human LIV 1 family members
image_ava
unmadly 18.10.2022 - 01:31
The surgery entails liposuction, surgical excision of the breast tissue with the goal of a masculine contoured chest generic">https://bestcialis20mg.com]generic cialis 20mg LC MS MS MS Measurements of the Levels of m 6 A in mRNA
image_ava
kevaskine 18.10.2022 - 06:09
Combination not recommended by British Herbal Medicine Association cialis">http://bestcialis20mg.com]cialis and viagra sales 2 ОјT rms field; a sinusoidal, 60 Hz, 1
image_ava
optogue 18.10.2022 - 10:38
buy">https://bestcialis20mg.com]buy cialis online overnight shipping Veronesi U, Luini A, Del Vecchio M, et al
image_ava
antindy 18.10.2022 - 12:56
02 ãð 25 ãð øèíãýí ò ðõýö 0 generic">http://bestcialis20mg.com]generic cialis
image_ava
Optitle 18.10.2022 - 19:22
New England Journal of Medicine, 375 8, 794 798 cialis">http://bestcialis20mg.com]cialis PMID 33611335 Free PMC article
image_ava
Esselfpaf 18.10.2022 - 20:58
Stanton RBuPPcHdZLUC 6 27 2022 cialis">http://bestcialis20mg.com]cialis buy
image_ava
lewheta 18.10.2022 - 22:49
Fluoxetina, clorhidrato de 20 mg Caja x 10 tabs canadian">http://bestcialis20mg.com]canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg KPNA2 is a nuclear export protein that contributes to aberrant localisation of key proteins and poor prognosis of breast cancer
image_ava
Lushisk 19.10.2022 - 04:29
cialis">https://bestcialis20mg.com]cialis for sale in usa Bottle of 30 tablets, NDC 0904 6195 46
image_ava
shourne 19.10.2022 - 05:01
40 mg 1mL Solution Irrigation Biomet Biologics 2010 01 01 2010 09 04 US Cytra 3 Sodium citrate 500 mg 5mL Citric acid monohydrate 334 mg 5mL Potassium citrate monohydrate 550 mg 5mL Syrup Oral Pegasus Laboratories 2006 05 05 2009 10 17 US Cytra 3 Sodium citrate 500 mg 5mL Citric acid monohydrate 334 mg 5mL Potassium citrate monohydrate 550 mg 5mL Syrup Oral Cypress Pharmaceuticals, Inc 2008 07 29 2014 10 11 US Cytra 2 Sodium citrate dihydrate 500 mg 5mL Citric acid monohydrate 334 mg 5mL Solution Oral Cypress Pharmaceuticals, Inc buy">http://bestcialis20mg.com]buy cialis online safely
image_ava
Sogaspess 20.10.2022 - 10:11
levitra seroquel dosage for mania Figures will also show that more students have been entered for tough subjects such as maths and science because of mounting demand for the disciplines from top universities and employers purchase">http://bestcialis20mg.com]purchase cialis
image_ava
Uttetty 20.10.2022 - 14:35
generic">https://bestcialis20mg.com]generic cialis for sale Novedex XT was created to be more potent, based on binding times and binding ability how fast and tight it sticks to the target molecule, than other PCT and Estrogen blockers
image_ava
SillUnona 20.10.2022 - 16:53
I then said, So again I ask you, you would agree that pulling fake hair does not cause the same damage as pulling someone s hair out of their scalp, right ">https://bestcialis20mg.com]п»їcialis
image_ava
Abracyday 21.10.2022 - 01:46
Endometrial adenocarcinomas have been the most frequently reported tumor associated with tamoxifen use buy">http://bestcialis20mg.com]buy cialis 5mg online bisacodyl martins pharmacy winchester va Гў ItГў s really difficult to learn how to walk again, Гў said Holmes, who had two screws permanently inserted in his foot
image_ava
Affesmede 21.10.2022 - 02:33
how">http://bestcialis20mg.com]how to buy cialis Itneeded a 42 billion euro bailout of its banks last year, withmost of the problems among its raft of smaller lenders
image_ava
Mackjaike 21.10.2022 - 02:41
Treatment with chemotherapy did not yield better control over GI symptoms compared with tamoxifen buy">https://bestcialis20mg.com]buy generic cialis
image_ava
CrydayLat 21.10.2022 - 14:26
376, 104 109 2016 cialis">http://bestcialis20mg.com]cialis generic
image_ava
Upserma 22.10.2022 - 17:03
Kenneth lvElscFOUdxzFohJgCM 6 20 2022 purchase">https://bestcialis20mg.com]purchase cialis online cheap Clinical surveillance of all women using estrogen alone or estrogen plus progestogen therapy important; perform adequate diagnostic measures, including directed or random endometrial sampling when indicated to rule out malignancy in postmenopausal women with undiagnosed persistent or recurring abnormal genital bleeding with unknown etiology
image_ava
grourge 22.10.2022 - 22:51
Among all breast cancer survivors, body weight before breast cancer diagnosis was weakly and positively related to breast cancer death and all cause mortality but not recurrence Table 2 cialis">https://bestcialis20mg.com]cialis 20 mg
image_ava
hathluddy 23.10.2022 - 03:45
2011; Moran Crusio et al viagra">http://bestcialis20mg.com]viagra cialis online 23 mmol, EDAC 52 mg; 0
image_ava
Dizappapy 23.10.2022 - 17:30
viagra">http://bestcialis20mg.com]viagra vs cialis In the same study, prolongation of the QT interval on the electrocardiogram was noted when patients were given doses higher than 250 mg m loading dose, followed by maintenance doses of 80 mg m of Tamoxifen Mylan tamoxifen citrate given twice a day
image_ava
sealfug 24.10.2022 - 08:21
overnight">http://bestcialis20mg.com]overnight cialis delivery Nuclear accumulations of p53 and Mdm2 are accompanied by reductions in c Abl and p300 in zinc depleted human hepatoblastoma cells
image_ava
Tifsalles 25.10.2022 - 10:57
daily">https://bestcialis20mg.com]daily cialis online A suspicious finding on a scan often leads to biopsies and other medical tests that have costs and complications of their own
image_ava
Fetaste 25.10.2022 - 17:20
cialis">http://bestcialis20mg.com]cialis online reviews In particular, SMC contributed to a Myh11 Lgals3 population with a chondrocyte like gene signature that was markedly reduced with SMC Klf4 knockout
image_ava
gerabroge 26.10.2022 - 02:56
0 years at aEC diagnosis, 70 buy">https://bestcialis20mg.com]buy cialis 20mg Their babies will undergo extensive medical examinations at age one and two years to see if there is any developmental or behavioral affects of alcohol in those women who drank during pregnancy
image_ava
Veincaf 26.10.2022 - 14:53
At 5 years, patients who were treated with Arimidex experienced a 17 reduced risk of a cancer recurrence compared to those treated with tamoxifen lasix">https://buylasixon.com]lasix effect on potassium 5 month increase in the median survival time of patients with metastatic breast cancer over the past decade
image_ava
haileasia 26.10.2022 - 20:36
Patients would be randomized to a lipophilic statin likely atorvastatin or placebo and followed longitudinally buy">https://stromectol.bar]buy stromectol 6 mg online 2001 May; 297 2 688 95
image_ava
Idedojame 27.10.2022 - 00:27
cialis">https://abrandcialis.com]cialis prescription online Dotted line indicates when treatment was ended
image_ava
Abracyday 27.10.2022 - 03:32
9 All women on hormone therapy should be under clinical supervision and aware of the potential risks and benefits lasix">https://buylasixon.com]lasix hyponatremia
image_ava
OrgagPess 27.10.2022 - 09:24
cheap">https://bestcialis20mg.com]cheap cialis online pharmacy Patient characteristics and indication for oophorectomy did not differ significantly based on tamoxifen exposure
image_ava
Addexia 27.10.2022 - 14:24
This side study investigated the effect of chemotherapy on thyroid function and the extent to which it can predict pathological complete response pCR in patients with early breast cancer taking part in NEOZOTAC phase III trial, randomizing between neoadjuvant chemotherapy with or without additional zoledronic acid spironolactone">https://buylasixon.com]spironolactone and lasix
image_ava
CrydayLat 27.10.2022 - 18:07
2006, 27 541 550 buy">https://stromectol.buzz]buy stromectol pills online
image_ava
Crorryder 27.10.2022 - 19:27
Dardiotis E, Aloizou AM, Markoula S, Siokas V, Tsarouhas K, Tzanakakis G, Libra M, Kyritsis AP, Brotis AG, Aschner M, Gozes I, Bogdanos DP, Spandidos DA, Mitsias PD, Tsatsakis A stromectol.">https://stromectol.bar]stromectol.
image_ava
Biobiagon 27.10.2022 - 19:41
Dose response studies in the same rat model demonstrated that more than 90 inhibition of STS activity in tumors was necessary to induce tumor shrinkage stromectol">https://stromectol.cloud]stromectol tab 3 mg
image_ava
unionebek 27.10.2022 - 23:07
PubMed 8259487 how">https://buylasixon.com]how long does it take for lasix to start working About 5 to 10 of breast cancers are thought to be hereditary, meaning the cancer is linked to mutations in genes passed from parent to child
image_ava
Uploaph 28.10.2022 - 01:08
The targeting vector, pFloxP Flp Neo reverse, was provided by the Transgenic Core, University of Michigan stromectol">https://stromectol.cloud]stromectol dosage for pinworms Presence of other foods in the stomach
image_ava
foosila 28.10.2022 - 06:25
how">https://stromectol.cloud]how to take stromectol She joined FDA in 1986
image_ava
ShouffGor 28.10.2022 - 08:57
stromectol">https://stromectol.autos]stromectol farmacia A lot of us have missed more than a few exits
image_ava
Scourne 28.10.2022 - 16:11
stromectol">https://stromectol.autos]stromectol dosage for pinworms tdTomato positive LEC clusters corresponding to our definition four cells or fewer were also observed in similar locations relative to the midline ahead of the migration front, near the neural tube in the lumbar region of the embryo Fig
image_ava
Gredorm 28.10.2022 - 21:51
mag">https://buylasixon.com]mag 3 lasix renal scan The researchers identified that GPR108, a G protein coupled receptor, served as a molecular lock to the cell
image_ava
foosila 29.10.2022 - 01:53
com Having failed to dismantle politically and socially knottyobstacles to growth, Asia has instead relied on low interestrates and massive borrowing to keep its economies expanding, particularly since the 2008 09 global financial crisis thatprompted the Fed to start aggressively buying bonds buy">https://stromectol.bar]buy ivermectin pills online
image_ava
Esselfpaf 30.10.2022 - 18:46
Current Opinion in Oncology, 32 6, 594 602 lasix">https://buylasixon.com]lasix liquido
image_ava
Geoffnene 31.10.2022 - 00:12
A common estrogenic side effect as a result of this is the development of gynecomastia where">https://stromectol.autos]where can i buy stromectol ivermectin
image_ava
unmadly 31.10.2022 - 07:13
cialis">https://abrandcialis.com]cialis generic 5mg This can check for any signs of bone thinning
image_ava
aspiple 31.10.2022 - 08:06
When used in conjunction with other topical treatments and lifestyle changes, such as staying away from stressful environments and eating a balanced diet, optimal results can be achieved where">https://stromectol.autos]where can i buy stromectol Risk adapted therapy for infantile myofibromatosis in children
image_ava
acquaimar 31.10.2022 - 09:00
Dante cbLbuBdhQIHsTEb 5 20 2022 generic">https://bestcialis20mg.com]generic cialis tadalafil Lu 23 Suppl 1 S73 7 Santini et al S adenosylmethionine AdoMet supplementation for treatment of chemotherapy induced liver injury
image_ava
curergels 31.10.2022 - 09:58
Like Sherry, Sheila also complained about her lack of memory and organizational skills caused by chemotherapy lasix">https://buylasixon.com]lasix overdose
image_ava
surcese 31.10.2022 - 11:56
nizoral amoxicillin for tooth infection how many days Salmonella is known to contaminate poultry flocks in the United States doxycycline">https://buydoxycyclineon.com]doxycycline pills black market
image_ava
OrgagPess 31.10.2022 - 16:22
buy">https://abrandcialis.com]buy cialis professional Darwish M, et al
image_ava
Kixabusia 31.10.2022 - 19:05
Iron 30mg Tablets buy">https://stromectol.homes]buy stromectol ivermectin online nebivolol tab

Pages