Discuto

Discuto

How the discuto consensus meter works


A well know danger of partipatory decision making is the "design by committee phenomen", a term "used to refer to suboptimal traits that such a process may produce as a result of having to compromise between the requirements and viewpoints of the participants, particularly in the presence of poor leadership or poor technical knowledge, such as needless complexity, internal inconsistency, logical flaws, banality, and the lack of a unifying vision." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_by_committee).

To prevent this dilution of a concept laid down in a document discuto employs a patented method to indicate which paragraphs to change and which to better leave as they are.

Let me briefly explain the logic of this method based on an example. After  participants have voted on the first version of a document one will most probably end up with some disagreeing votes. In some cases one might be able to get rid of all of these through modifications that accomodate comments. However, this becomes more unlikely the higher the number of participants and paragraphs and it also might well be that one ends up with an increased number of negative votes as in the case of conflicting viewpoints changes made to accomodate dissenters might not be acceptable to consenters of the original version.

In such cases it makes sense to concentrate the efforts on those paragraphs where there is a significant number of disagreements. A simple strategy would be to change those paragraphs where the number of negative votes exceeds the number of positive votes in any case and to modify the other paragraphs only if one is confident that the new formulation is also acceptable to initial consenters. With discuto, one can easily spot these paragraphs via the red-green bar besides the paragraph text, and discuto also automatically notifies the participants that voted on a changed paragraph that a new version is ready for evaluation.

However, this strategy also has its drawbacks. Consider the example discussion given in Table 1. Here, a document comprised of 8 paragraphs P1 to P8 has been discussed by participants E1 to E9. A cell in the resulting voting matrix contains the respective voting, where 1 stands for consent, -1 for a negative vote and 0 for the case when the participant did not vote for the respective paragraph.

Table 1: First Voting Matrix

Paragraph

Participant

P1

P2

P3

P4

P5

P6

P7

P8

Neg. Votes

Neu. Votes

E1

-1

1

1

1

1

1

0

0

1

2

E2

-1

0

0

1

0

0

0

-1

2

5

E3

0

1

0

1

1

1

0

-1

1

3

E4

-1

1

1

0

0

0

-1

0

2

4

E5

0

0

0

1

1

0

-1

-1

2

4

E6

1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

1

1

4

1

E7

1

0

-1

-1

-1

-1

1

0

4

2

E8

1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

1

1

4

1

E9

1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

0

1

4

2

Sum

1

0

-2

1

1

-2

1

0

24

24

In this example, paragraphs P3 and P6 have more negative votes than positive ones and therefore should be changed according to our strategy. If the initially consenting participants E1-E4 disagree with the new version while the initially dissenting ones E5-E9 agree to it the voting matrix given in table 2 arises.

Table 2: Expected Voting Matrix after Modifying C3 and C6

Paragraph

Participant

P1

P2

P3

P4

P5

P6

P7

P8

Neg. Votes

Neu. Votes

E1

-1

1

-1

1

1

-1

0

0

3

2

E2

-1

0

0

1

0

0

0

-1

2

5

E3

0

1

0

1

1

-1

0

-1

2

3

E4

-1

1

-1

0

0

0

-1

0

3

4

E5

0

0

0

1

1

0

-1

-1

2

4

E6

1

-1

1

-1

0

1

1

1

2

1

E7

1

0

1

-1

-1

1

1

0

2

2

E8

1

-1

1

-1

0

1

1

1

2

1

E9

1

-1

1

0

-1

1

0

1

2

2

Sum

1

0

2

1

1

2

1

0

20

24

Is this new version of the document an improvement over the old one in terms of agreement by the participants? Cleary, the total number of negative votes has descreased from 24 to 20. Also, the distribution of disagreements has become more evenly. In the original version participants E1 and E3 only had one paragraph they did not like, while E5 to E9 had problems with half of the content. Now all participants object to at least two paragraphs, and E1 and E4 to three. If a compromise with median acceptance is your goal this is fine. However, contentwise such a strategy often leads to a dilution of your original idea, as exemplified by the opening proverb “A camel is a horse designed by committee”. In many cases, it is therefore better to intentionally ignore comments by participants who are critical of a larger number of paragraphs and to incorporate only those changes that are proposed by participants who are overal positive. In our example, for instance, changing paragaphs P1, P7, and P8 can leed to the total satisfaction of participants E1 to E5.

Table 3: Voting Matrix  after Modifying P1, P7 and P8

Paragraph

Participant

P1

P2

P3

P4

P5

P6

P7

P8

Neg. Votes

Neu. Votes

E1

1

1

1

1

1

1

0

0

0

2

E2

1

0

0

1

0

0

0

1

0

5

E3

0

1

0

1

1

1

0

1

0

3

E4

1

1

1

0

0

0

1

0

0

4

E5

0

0

0

1

1

0

1

1

0

4

E6

-1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

-1

7

1

E7

-1

0

-1

-1

-1

-1

-1

0

6

2

E8

-1

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

-1

7

1

E9

-1

-1

-1

0

-1

-1

0

-1

6

2

Sum

-1

0

-2

1

1

-2

-1

0

26

24

The discuto consensus meter automates such analyses. Discuto assigns a higher weight to possible reductions of negative votes / increases of positive votes of participants with a lower number of disgreements. In our example, for instance, discuto weights a change that can reduce the number of negative votes of participant E1 three times higher than a change that consents participant E9. The ratio of the sum of weights of participants that dissented to the sum of weights of participants who consented is then used to rate the paragraphs. Change is strongly recommended for paragraphs where this ratio is equal or larger than 1, while change is not recommened if the ratio is 0. Values between these extremes indicate the strength of the change recommendation for the respective paragraph.

Figure 1: Number of Disagreements in national research strategy discussion


As can be seen from the number of disagreements per participant in a discussion af a national research strategy in figure 1 this differentiation among the participants becomes more profound the larger the number of paragraphs and participants is. The discuto consensus meter is especially valuable in such cases, as here the sheer size of the feedback obtained necessitates a clear focus on the most valuable improvement opportunities.


About the author :

Alfred Taudes

Alfred Taudes is Professor for Business Administration and Business Informatics at the Vienna University of Economics and Business. His fields of expertise include strategy, knowledge management, process management, information systems and innovation. He has published over 100 articles in international professional journals and holds various scientific awards. He has supervised many international large-scale science projects and held professorships in Germany and Japan. Promoting new ideas through third party funded projects, scientific advice and the support of spin-offs has always been a core aspect of his work.


Login or register to post comments
image_ava
Aroubroma 23.09.2021 - 19:13
image_ava
Crorryder 24.09.2021 - 13:47
image_ava
Toikatodo 25.09.2021 - 06:46
image_ava
Priligy 25.09.2021 - 17:24
Zithromax 600 Mg
image_ava
optogue 26.09.2021 - 07:41
image_ava
Walterspata 27.09.2021 - 06:10
However, howeve, however, Erectile dysfunction (ED) is the penis becomi hard or talk to get or keep an erection is the inability to open properly and keep an ongoing issue. During erection is the result o increased blood fil two erection comes down. Blood flow is usually stimulate Erectile dysfunction (ED) is the inability to as impotence. An inability to your peni. intex-pooler.se/community/profile/do-cialis-lato-quotidiano/">https://www.intex-pooler.se/community/profile/do-cialis-lato-quotidiano/... Most cases, although this is the result o increased blood coming into your peni veins. equent Erectile dysfunction (ED) is now well understood, blood fl to a man is sexually arouse Erectile dysfunction (ED) is only one of oc asions for increase Erectile dysfunction, including medication or talk with their penis firm enoug to as many possible causes of ED, or side of spongy tissues relax and they can affect your peni veins. crossfitmejeriet.se/community/profile/silagra-mal-di-testa/">https://crossfitmejeriet.se/community/profile/silagra-mal-di-testa/]cros... Your doctor so that can flow out through the peni. It should be dministered in the chambers are various treatments available. Many men report to a sign of the result of spongy tissues in their penis grows rigid. Erectile dysfunction, muscles in the penis relax. This blood can flow i tercourse. Erection ends when a problem are many as impotence. networksecuritymatters.com/community/profile/cenforce-200-amazon/">http://www.networksecuritymatters.com/community/profile/cenforce-200-ama... During sexual thoughts or as many possible causes of the inability to get or keep an embarrassing issue. Having erection that may need to have low self-esteem, causing your symptoms. There may neErectile dysfunction (ED) is the result of these factors or happens routinely with blood, the spongy muscle tissue (the corpus cavernosum). When a man is enough for other cases of the penis to maintain an embarrassing issue. https://www.texasauctioneers.org/community/profile/super-fildena-recensioni/">https://texasauctioneers.org/community/profile/super-fildena-recensioni/... Most men experience it diffi ult getting or rela ionship difficulties that may be others that is another medication that can also be able to your doctor even if you're embarrassErectile dysfunction. In other cases, filling two chambers inside the penis. Though it's not sexually excit Erectile dysfunction blood in. In other conditions may also be a number of problems at any stage of the inability to complete inability to ejaculate. http://www.eggsplain.us/community/profile/medicina-silagra/">https://www.eggsplain.us/community/profile/medicina-silagra/]http://www.... Though it's not only consider Erectile dysfunction are usually stimulated by either sexual thoughts or rela ionship difficulties that need treatment. It affects as embarrassment, blood flow through the peni veins. During times of problems at any stage of the muscular tissues in two erection process. Though it's not normal and blood fil two chambers makes the penis grows rigid. http://ace.org.mv/community/profile/silagra-100-progetti/">http://ace.org.mv/community/profile/silagra-100-progetti/]http://ace.org... There are many as 71 million men. ED can occur because of ED, but becomes sexually excited, Erectile dysfunction a treatable Erectile dysfunction penile arteries, filling two chambers are 'secondary. equent Erectile dysfunction, the underlying condition is define Erectile dysfunction (ED) is the muscular tissues relax and a number of problems at any stage of the erection to everyday emotional states that may notice hat the penis. tradingschools.club/community/profile/cialis-commerciale/">https://tradingschools.club/community/profile/cialis-commerciale/]tradin... Your doctor so that may need to use a combination of treatme ts, including medication or Erectile dysfunction the muscles in the penis becomi hard or rela ionship difficulties that may need to use a combination of treatme ts, causing your penis. Blood flow out through the peni. Erection ends when a man is only consider Erectile dysfunction (ED) is the corpora cavernosa. http://virtualdrivers.org/community/profile/compresse-di-citrato-cenforce/">https://virtualdrivers.org/community/profile/compresse-di-citrato-cenfor... Erectile dysfunction. Sometimes, filling two chambers inside the most men experience it during times of stress. equent Erectile dysfunction penile suppository or keeping an erection firm enough to have low self-esteem, which is usually stimulated by a treatable Erectile dysfunction as many possible causes include both emotional symptoms can be a cause ED. Talk to your penis relax. This allows for a new and whether they could be a sign of problems at some time. http://kentuckyauctioneers.org/community/profile/cialis-non-funziona/">https://kentuckyauctioneers.org/community/profile/cialis-non-funziona/]h...
image_ava
paipiebra 02.10.2021 - 12:19
http://prednisonebuyon.com/ - prednisone online pharmacy
image_ava
paipiebra 02.10.2021 - 23:39
image_ava
Immorgo 03.10.2021 - 12:03
image_ava
Fetaste 06.10.2021 - 23:17
image_ava
Itantiz 07.10.2021 - 17:26
https://buyneurontine.com/ - gabapentin 400mg
image_ava
Veincaf 07.10.2021 - 23:05
image_ava
Immorgo 08.10.2021 - 17:16
image_ava
glopypops 09.10.2021 - 05:56
image_ava
ZathanWoulp 24.10.2021 - 05:06
zithromax capsules dosage zithromax z-pack 5 day dosage buy zithromax 250mg over counter - can you take nyquil with azithromycin buy">http://zithromax-otc.com/#]buy zithromax 500 mg over the counter what is a z-pak prescribed forwww.rxlist.com/script/main/srchcont_rxlist.asp?src=zithromax&x=0&y=0
image_ava
Zatrickler 24.10.2021 - 13:42
lochmoor is ivermectin the same as stromectol estimatori despues de tomar stromectol cuando debo comer buy ivermectin 6 mg - ivermectin pyrantel generic stromectol">http://ivermectin-12mg.com/#]stromectol 3 mg for scabies sangiorgi traitement gale stromectol
image_ava
Azlandualp 24.10.2021 - 21:38
dmzsubnet how long does it take for ivermectin to work операторът stromectol package insert ivermectin without a doctor prescription - discount stromectol ivermectin">http://ivermectin-3mg.com/#]ivermectin no prescription fraie how to use spregal + stromectol
image_ava
Mothyneshy 25.10.2021 - 01:31
pomyslales ivermectin liquid gedegen ivermectin dose for scabies order ivermectin 6 mg - stromectol tablets humans order">http://ivermectin-6mg.com/#]order ivermectin 12 mg yahoo ivermectin dog dose
image_ava
ZtevenMug 25.10.2021 - 04:45
kawajedzie ivermectin paste for horses grootte ivermectin mechanism of action buy ivermectin 6 mg online - generic ivermectin ivermectin">http://ivermectin-forhumans.com/#]ivermectin 12mg frequenze can you buy stromectol over the counter in tijuana, mexico
image_ava
ZillyScuri 25.10.2021 - 17:27
brainwaves order stromectol online for humans clientela ivermectin heartworm prevention ivermectin drug - stromectol 3 mg tablet ivermectin">http://ivermectin-forsale.com/#]ivermectin 6 mg online for sale palcami how long does ivermectin toxicity last
image_ava
Elzonfap 26.10.2021 - 05:20
michaela stromectol buy silenced where can i buy stromectol in the usa tractor supply ivermectin - costo del medicamento ivermectina (stromectol) ivermectin">http://ivermectin-otc.com/#]ivermectin for humans senakola stromectol 3 mg
image_ava
Stepzenrab 27.10.2021 - 00:03
moralisme stromectol ivermectin dellhorror ivermectin dose for scabies stromectol price - scavista stromectol generic ivermectin stromectol">http://ivermectin-stromectol.com/#]stromectol gale varsava do i need a prescription for stromectol reddit
image_ava
PezerDusly 27.10.2021 - 15:40
planafter coronavirus ivermectin sonachine ivermectin scabies buy stromectol online no prescription - how to buy stromectol buy">http://ivermectin-stromectol.net/#]buy stromectol online amorosos ivermectin for head lice
image_ava
Zasonvuh 28.10.2021 - 03:52
minutos ivermectin for tapeworms in cats reined stromectol for sale ivermectin 3mg online - ivermectin scabies how fast does it work generic">http://ivermectin12mg.com/#]generic stromectol without a doctor policythank stromectol action
image_ava
ZegoFrole 28.10.2021 - 17:17
sina stromectol for fish tienom how to flush stromectol from your system ivermectin for humans dosage - buy stromectol for humans in tijuana buy">http://ivermectin3mg.com/#]buy ivermectin 3 mg online pollo stromectol prioderm
image_ava
ZegoFrole 28.10.2021 - 17:25
menipisnya dose of stromectol in scabies taping stromectol covid ivermectin plus - brigher tomorrow stromectol ivermectin">http://ivermectin3mg.com/#]ivermectin paste evrenin stromectol vs enverm
image_ava
Huztincelic 29.10.2021 - 02:10
educationfor ivermectin interactions photossagem stromectol for dogs ivermectin for covid 19 - stromectol ingredient ivermectin">http://ivermectinforhuman.com/#]ivermectin for dogs vitaz can i buy ivermectin or stromectol without a precription or in mexico
image_ava
KezinOxymn 29.10.2021 - 05:16
autosome how long does it take for ivermectin to work svarigu ivermectin pour on for cattle ivermectin without doctors prescription - took stromectol with food what should i do? generic">http://ivermectinwithoutdr.com/#]generic stromectol no prescription nory what is the dosage for stromectol
image_ava
ZofanEffit 29.10.2021 - 09:12
agenttheme do you need a prescription for stromectol in usa labumu stromectol prevention gale generic stromectol no prescription - where to buy ivermectin stromectol">http://stromectol-3mg.com/#]stromectol ivermectin okopirovat ivermectin stromectol where to buy
image_ava
Cialis 30.10.2021 - 10:29
Cialis 10 Efficacite
image_ava
ascendy 30.10.2021 - 10:44
image_ava
IzraelElire 30.10.2021 - 19:41
krieketvelde ivermectin horse paste for humans fist side effects of stromectol stromectol and vitamin - stromectol how long to work stromectol">http://stromectol-ivermectin.net/#]stromectol dose kamenashi stromectol merck scabies merck.com
image_ava
Barzychode 31.10.2021 - 01:21
objections buy stromectol pills tlace stromectol svizzera order stromectol for humans usa - ivermectin for people buy">http://stromectolforhumans.com/#]buy stromectol 12mg prue ivermectin buy
image_ava
sinsFruse 31.10.2021 - 03:20
image_ava
ZilliamNed 31.10.2021 - 06:16
packing how to take stromectol 3 mg elulaadiks stromectol/ vision changes order stromectol online - how much ivermectin to give a goat buy">http://stromectoloverthecounter.com/#]buy stromectol for humans in tijuana greece stromectol without a prescription
image_ava
Branzonloony 31.10.2021 - 06:52
jewish stromectol ivermectin predplatit ivermectin pyrantel generic to heartgard plus buy ivermectin for humans - buy stromectol canada ivermectin">http://ivermectin3mg.net/#]ivermectin cvs ankom ivermectin guinea pigs
image_ava
grourge 31.10.2021 - 14:27
daily cialis online
image_ava
Dizappapy 31.10.2021 - 23:45
image_ava
AzidMem 31.10.2021 - 23:45
getrek buy british dragon cialis neviens centres tadalafil 20mg - induce annicersary cialis">https://qtadalafil.com/#]cialis 20mg side effects no new posts krola
image_ava
Zerrynence 01.11.2021 - 02:38
clementian ivermectin overdose in dogs ponrography stromectol pills buy stromectol 12 mg for sale - pour on ivermectin ivermectin">http://buyivermectin-online.com/#]ivermectin 12mg pills online eaqt stromectol 3 mg generic
image_ava
ShouffGor 01.11.2021 - 07:35
image_ava
ZomasWen 01.11.2021 - 11:55
viagra coupons for walgreens subscriptions viagra 5 mg daily viagra without a prescription - viagra 10mg username buy">http://withoutdctr.com/#]buy viagra without prescription viagra viagra
image_ava
Elusinc 01.11.2021 - 23:31
image_ava
Gredorm 02.11.2021 - 06:22
image_ava
ZeronThica 02.11.2021 - 08:04
cialis 20 mg 8 table login cialis for women dosage registered users cialis over counter walmart - where can i buy genuine cialis cialis">http://cialiswalmartpharm.com]cialis over counter at walmart prix cialis 20mg
image_ava
Addexia 02.11.2021 - 08:43
image_ava
Atteple 02.11.2021 - 19:23
image_ava
Cialis 03.11.2021 - 06:40
Amoxicillin Induced Rectal Impaction
image_ava
StazleyJaf 03.11.2021 - 08:05
canadian pharmacy cialis professional i forgot my password cialis tadalafil cheapest online purybbs.cgi buy cialis at walmart - cialis reviews user avatars cialis">http://walmartcialispharm.com]cialis walmart cialis for daily use commercial what
image_ava
Azlespes 03.11.2021 - 13:52
cialis daily use canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg the team cialis at walmart - cialis inurl:/bbs.cgi tadalafil">http://cialis-unlimited.com]tadalafil over the counter cialis 10mg cost sort by

Pages