Measuring the Efficiency of Consultation, Participation and Engagement

Around the world citizens like you and me are being consulted about all sorts of things. What kind of digital future do we want? How do we spend our leisure time?  Where should new homes be built? How much local tax are we prepared to pay? What should future provision for the Arts be like? Where should a new waste incinerator be located? Of course it’s not only towns and cities who want information from us; it’s health providers, transport undertakings, central governments and a lot more besides.

One thing is certain: there is a lot of consultation, participation and engagement going on.  And they all seem to use different processes to get our views as citizens, service users or consumers. There are traditional questionnaire surveys, focus groups, e-participation exercises, citizens’ juries, deliberative conferences, world cafés, town hall meetings – the list goes on and on.

Wouldn’t it be good if we knew how efficient these different processes were, and how well they perform their common task of communicating our views as citizens? And what if we could compare the efficiency of all these different processes in different circumstances?  That would be great, wouldn’t it?

I have developed a precise measure of the efficiency of consultation, participation and engagement processes which will enable us to do just that. Drawing on established ideas from ecology and communications theory, the key proposition is that the efficiency of a consultation should be assessed in terms of the information flow it generates.

I have created a new tool for measuring this information flow. It is called the Effective Number of Issues (ENI) and adapts a technique ecologists use to measure the biodiversity of a community of plants or animals. If we think of the information flow as giving rise to a community of issues we can use the ENI to calculate the diversity of this community and thus the efficiency of the process.

To calculate the ENI you need a list of all the different issues that are used in, or emerge from, the consultation process, and a count of the number of times each one appears. You also need the ENI formula, which is ENI = exp(H’), where H´= - ∑px ln(px). In this formula ‘p’ is the relative frequency of each issue and ‘ln’ is the natural logarithm. The calculations are quite straightforward using Excel and there is a step by step guide to the procedure here: https://www.discuto.io/en/info-page/eni-calculation.

Armed with the ENI we can now rate the efficiency of different consultation, participation and engagement processes, and explore what makes one process more efficient than another. As a start, Alfred Taudes, Hannes Leo and I have used the new tool to measure the efficiency of the idea generation stage of the Vienna Digital Agenda e-participation. The ENI for this process (145.9) is the highest ever recorded. Unless, of course, you know of a consultation process that can challenge Vienna for the top position? Do tell us!

About the author :

John May

Login or register to post comments
rama 26.05.2019 - 15:48

Hello.. I also a lover of xbox live But I faced difficulty when my subscription gone last.One day I search it on google that how xbox live can use free. Then a site provide me free xbox live codes now any hurdle can stop me to playing xbox live.

Sarahhamilton 16.07.2019 - 13:01

Profession the board is significant for the youthful age and we as a whole need to get this information Write My Essay - GetEssayDone. This workforce the board will assist you with building your very own profession.

Alfredal 31.10.2019 - 19:34

Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here.
prestamos rapidos sin papeleos y fiables con asnef

karimi 01.01.2020 - 12:40

بتن ریزی انواع مختلفی دارد که یکی از آنها بتن ریزی کف محوطه می باشد.قصد داریم در این مقاله به آموزش بتن ریزی کف محوطه بپردازیم.

بتن ریزی کف محوطه امروزه برای پیمانکارن دارای اهمیت فراوانی است. امروزه یکی از ساده ترین بتن ریزی ها مربوط به بتن ریزی کف محوطه می باشد که در اکثرا ساختمانها و سوله ها و کف پارکینگ مورد استفاده قرار می گیرد. در صورت امکان برای راحتی کار خودتان از میکسر استفاده کنید تا هم از سرعت و هم از نظر هزینه به صرفه باشد. اگر بخواهید بتن ریزی کف محوطه را به صورت دستی انجام بدهید هم زمان بر و هم صرفه اقتصادی ندارد.

بتن ریزی کف محوطه در تابستان به دلیل گرما و استفاده آب فراوان امکان دارد که مشکلاتی را به وجود بیاورد که در اینجا به چند مورد اشاره خواهیم کرد:

ممکن کیفیت و استاندارد بتن را پایین بیاورد

مقاومت بتن را به دلیل مصرف زیاد آب از بین می برد
کاهش یک نواختی سطح بتن به ویژه در مجاورت قالب ها
ممکن است به دلیل مصرف آب زیاد رنگ بتن تغییر کنند
مراحل اجرای بتن ریزی کف محوطه در بتن جام :
مرحله اول این است که سطح زمین را برای اجرای کف سازی آماده و تمیز کنید
یکی از مهم ترین مراحل بتن ریزی کف این است که اول سطح خاک را تراز و سپس برای جلوگیری از جذب آب از بتن مگر استفاده کنیم
اجرای بتن ریزی و ماله کشی برای صاف و هم تراز کردن سطح بتن از دیگر قسمت های مهم در بتن ریزی چیست کف می باشد.
اجرای عملیات ماله کشی به دلیل صاف و تراز کردن سطح بتن.
و در آخر اجرای آرماتور بندی از قسمت های مهم برای بتن ریزی کف محوطه می باشد.

sumandesai 15.10.2019 - 12:15
muneerahmed400@... 03.11.2019 - 13:56

Man's lives, such as uncontrolled huge amounts, definitely not while countries furthermore reefs, challenging to seismic disturbance upward perfect apply. Ayurvedic treatment for fibromyalgia

Christianclg 10.12.2019 - 05:44

Thanks for givining this space. I would like to use this spce to add our link. We are providing the best infrastructure among colleges in bangalore. If you are looking to best BBA Aviation colleges in Bangalore, the below link will help you to find best colleges in bangalore.

BSc Cardiac Care Technology Colleges In Bangalore

BSc Perfusion Technology Colleges In Bangalore

Best Colleges In Bangalore

david001 10.08.2019 - 12:31

thanks to post such a nice content. There are also many Blog Sites for Best Info and Updated New and many More Amazing Hacks.

eddie007 18.09.2019 - 08:23

My 1st anniversary is comming on next month so i found a website anniversary video songs hindi download where i can download free romatic short video for whatsappp 

Deangelo249 18.09.2019 - 22:23

Some sort of thing can discuss in the current session of essay pro in the next week. What is the future of art Education. I think the future of this thing are bright. So you don't have to worry about the artistic future.

dermotashborn 28.10.2019 - 08:46

There is a lot of consultation, participation and engagement going on.

update the latest geometry dash full version

Christianclg 10.12.2019 - 05:47

If you are looking for Branding Agency in Riyadh or Marketing Company in Riyadh, the following links is for the best Branding and marketing agency based in Riyadh.

Branding Agency In Riyadh

Marketing Agency In Riyadh

Christianclg 10.12.2019 - 05:50

Here is the best plastic manufacturing company in Saudi Arabia. They are manufacturing Plastic Pallets and Plastic Crates under the Handling Solutions of Plastic Products. If you need the details of Handling Solutions products, you should click the following link.

Lucas Gerazd 05.11.2019 - 08:43

His prentation contains a lot of good opinions. I can understand it soundcloud to mp3

romandavis 21.11.2019 - 05:37

 is very interesting, but for the simplicity of the exposition, I will not mention other aspects. Thank you  for this post  I invite you to check my   coursework writing service for online writing help 

murli66 14.01.2020 - 09:03

so nice article sir keep posting these type of article for us . if you want to read my article then click here - bolly4u